I Have Been Told I Should Not Take NSAID'S However

I have been told I should not take NSAID'S however Tylenol is not doing it for me. I would like to take the least toxic NSAID'S and be monitored. kidney values. My labs are WNL now, I have arthritis in my knees, elbows, hands, back. I have tried turmeric & other natural remedies. I have had a foot sprain & have suffered for more than 2 weeks. I was given limited Indocin, and had relief, I am 58 years old and I am sick of the pain. I want my NSAID"S Back!!!!!!!