question-icon

Having Pulmonary Oedema But Hypostatic Pneumonia Is Suspected. Can An X-ray Give A Reliable Diagnosis?

default
Posted on Thu, 7 Nov 2013
Twitter Thu, 7 Nov 2013 Answered on
Twitter Mon, 25 Nov 2013 Last reviewed on
Question : (1) If a patient has pulmonary oedema but hypostatic pneumonia is suspected then can an X-ray give a reliable diagnosis? (2) If so, how? Is there an additional standard diagnostic test that can be used in these circumstances? (3) Finally, is there any way of telling whether a patient has hypostatic pneumonia or sepsis in these circumstance if two blood cultures are taken together and both are negative?
doctor
Answered by Dr. Shashi Dangwal (7 hours later)
Brief Answer: Clinical corelation and other tests may help. Detailed Answer: Hello, Thanks for posting your query on XXXXXXX On x XXXXXXX chest, it may not be always possible to differentiate Pul oedema from hypostatic pneumonia. However there are some signs which may point towards one diagnosis or the other. These are as follows: In pul oedema, there may be associated cardiomegaly with evidence of various chamber enlargement, kerley B lines and pleural effusion. There may be perihilar cuffing. In hypostatic pneumonia, there are fluffy, irregular, patchy opacities scattered all over, more peripherally. CT chest shows opacities to be more in the dependent areas. Clinical co relation along with other tests like echo and ct chest help in establishing diagnosis. Hypostatic pneumonia may occur by itself in a debilitated patient mostly confined to the bed or may be a part of sepsis which is common in such patients. Blood culture and sputum culture may yield results but are generally negative as by the time these tests are ordered patient has already been on antibiotics.However as mentioned above other tests and clinical correlation may help in diagnosis.
Above answer was peer-reviewed by : Dr. Shanthi.E
doctor
Answered by
Dr.
Dr. Shashi Dangwal

Pulmonologist

Practicing since :1979

Answered : 1157 Questions

Ask me a question
premium_optimized

The User accepted the expert's answer

Ask a Pulmonologist
Share on

Get personalised answers from verified doctor in minutes across 80+ specialties

161 Doctors Online

By proceeding, I accept the Terms and Conditions

HCM Blog Instant Access to Doctors
HCM Blog Questions Answered
HCM Blog Satisfaction
backtotop2
Having Pulmonary Oedema But Hypostatic Pneumonia Is Suspected. Can An X-ray Give A Reliable Diagnosis?

Brief Answer: Clinical corelation and other tests may help. Detailed Answer: Hello, Thanks for posting your query on XXXXXXX On x XXXXXXX chest, it may not be always possible to differentiate Pul oedema from hypostatic pneumonia. However there are some signs which may point towards one diagnosis or the other. These are as follows: In pul oedema, there may be associated cardiomegaly with evidence of various chamber enlargement, kerley B lines and pleural effusion. There may be perihilar cuffing. In hypostatic pneumonia, there are fluffy, irregular, patchy opacities scattered all over, more peripherally. CT chest shows opacities to be more in the dependent areas. Clinical co relation along with other tests like echo and ct chest help in establishing diagnosis. Hypostatic pneumonia may occur by itself in a debilitated patient mostly confined to the bed or may be a part of sepsis which is common in such patients. Blood culture and sputum culture may yield results but are generally negative as by the time these tests are ordered patient has already been on antibiotics.However as mentioned above other tests and clinical correlation may help in diagnosis.